The Size of the Praetorian Cohorts in the First and Second Centuries CE.
Guskov Evgeniy A.
The paper is devoted to the problem of determining the size of praetorian cohorts in the first and second centuries CE. Contrary to the ancient narrative tradition, which reports that the staff of each cohort of the Imperial Guard consisted of 1000 people, French historian M. Durry offered a number of arguments in favour of the view that their size was half as large. His hypothesis has been widely accepted in scholarship, but also had its critics who defend the reliability of ancient authors and point out the ambiguity of the conclusions that are obtained from the analysis of archaeological data and statistical calculations based on the material of the praetorian laterculi. Despite the possibility of ambiguous interpretations, the easiest way to account for the testimony of available sources is to accept the miliary status of the praetorian cohorts. The only existing obstacle is that the structure of the praetorian cohort was typical for quingenary units, but this feature is the result of the creation of the corps of imperial bodyguards from legionary soldiers in the period of the Second Triumvirate.
References:
Baillie Reynolds, P.K. 1923: The Troops Quartered in the Castra Peregrinorum. Journal of Roman Studies 13, 168–189.
Baillie Reynolds, P.K., Ashby, T. 1923: The Castra Peregrinorum. Journal of Roman Studies 13, 152–167.
Bannikov, A.V. 2013: Evolyutsiya rimskoy voyennoy sistemy v I–III vv. (ot Avgusta do Diokletiana) [Evolution of the Roman Military System in the I–III Centuries (from Augustus to Diocletian)]. Saint Petersburg.
Банников, А.В. Эволюция римской военной системы в I–III вв. (от Августа до Диоклетиана). СПб.
Bannikov, A.V. 2020: Rimskaya armiya epokhi printsipata. Organizatsiya, vooruzhenie, taktika [The Roman Army of the Principate Era. Organization, Weapons, Tactics]. Saint Petersburg.
Банников, А.В. Римская армия эпохи принципата. Организация, вооружение, тактика. СПб.
Bédoyère, G. de la 2017: Praetorian: The Rise and Fall of Rome’s Imperial Bodyguard. New Haven.
Bertinelli Angeli, M.G. 1974: Gli effettivi della legione e della coorte pretoria e i latercoli dei soldati ‘missi honesta missione’. Rendiconti dell’ Istituto Lombardo. Classe di Lettere 108, 3–12.
Bingham, S.J. 1997: The Praetorian Guard in the Political and Social Life of Julio-Claudian Rome. PhD thesis. Ottawa.
Bingham, S.J. 2013: The Praetorian Guard: A History of Rome’s Elite Special Forces. Waco.
Birley, E. 1969: Septimius Severus and the Roman Army. Epigraphische Studien 8, 63–82.
Birley, E. 1982: The Dating and Character of the Tract ‘De munitionibus castrorum’. In: G. Wirth (ed.), Romanitas–Christianitas: Untersuchungen zur Geschichte und Literatur der römischen Kaiserzeit. Johannes Straub zum 70. Geburtstag am 18. Oktober 1982 gewidmet. Berlin–Boston, 277–281.
Bowman, A.K., Thomas, J.D. 1991: A Military Strength Report from Vindolanda. Journal of Roman Studies 81, 62–73.
Breeze, D.J., Dobson, B. 1969: The Rome Cohorts and the Legionary Centurionate. Epigraphische Studien 8, 100–124.
Briessmann, A. 1955: Tacitus und das Flavische Geschichtsbild. Wiesbaden.
Chilver, G.E.F. 1979: A Historical Commentary on Tacitus’ Histories I and II. (Hermes, Einzelschriften, 10). Oxford.
Cosme, P. 2007: L’armée romaine VIIIe s. av. J.-C. – Ve s. ap. J.-C. Paris.
Cowan, R.H. 2002: Aspects of the Roman Field Army. The Praetorian Guard, Legio II Parthica and Legionary Vexillations, AD 193–238. PhD thesis. Glasgow.
Crimi, G. 2010: Tribù e origo nelle iscrizioni di pretoriani e urbaniciani arruolati in Italia: tre nuove attestazioni epigrafiche. In: M. Silvestrini (ed.), Le Tribù Romane. Atti della XVIe Rencontre sur lʼépigraphie (Bari 8–10 ottobre 2009). Bari, 329–336.
Dana, D., Zagreanu, R. 2017: Equites singulares Augusti originaires de la province de Dacie: épigraphie, onomastique, iconographie. Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 23/1, 139–171.
Dobson, B. 1970: The Centurionate and Social Mobility during the Principate. In: Recherches sur les structures sociales dans l’Antiquité classique. Caen 25–26 avril 1969. Paris, 99–116.
Dobson, B. 1982: Praefectus Castrorum Aegypti – a Reconsideration. Chronique d’Egypte 57/114, 322–337.
Domaszewski, A. von 1908: Die Rangordnung des römischen Heeres. Bonn.
Durry, M. 1938: Les cohortes prétoriennes. Paris.
Durry, M. 1954: Praetoriae cohortes. In: RE. Bd. 22/2, 1607–1634.
Echols, E. 1958: The Roman City Police: Origin and Development. Classical Journal 53/8, 377–385.
Eck, W. 2012: Diplomata militaria für Prätorianer, vor und seit Septimius Severus. Athenaeum 100, 321–336.
Freis, H. 1967: Die Cohortes Urbanae. Köln–Graz.
Frere, S.S. 1980: Hyginus and the First Cohort. Britannia 11, 51–60.
Gilliver, K. 2007: The Augustan Reform and the Structure of the Imperial Army. In: P. Erdkamp (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Army. Oxford, 183–200.
Grillone, A. 1987: Problemi tecnici e datazione del ‘De metatione castrorum’ dello ps.-Igino. Latomus 46/2, 399–412.
Groneman, S.A.J. 1832: Commentatio de militum praetorianorum apud Romanos historia. Utrecht.
Guskov, E.A. 2007: [On the Quingenary and Miliary Type of the Praetorian Cohorts]. Antiquitas iuventae 3, 181–190.
Гуськов, Е.А. К вопросу о квингенарном и милиарном типе преторианских когорт. Antiquitas iuventae 3, 181–190.
Guskov, E.A. 2008: [The Praetorians of Otho and Vitellius in the Guard of Vespasian: Some Remarks]. Antiquitas iuventae 4, 113–119.
Гуськов, Е.А. Преторианцы Отона и Вителлия в гвардии Веспасиана: несколько замечаний. Antiquitas iuventae 4, 113–119.
Guskov, E.A. 2014: [Praetorian Cohorts of the II Triumvirate Period]. Antiquitas iuventae 8–9, 138–151.
Гуськов, Е.А. Преторианские когорты периода II триумвирата. Antiquitas iuventae 8–9, 138–151.
Guskov, E.A. 2022: [The Praetorian Metilius Pudens and the Civil War in Rome]. Vestnik Sankt- Peterburgskogo universiteta. Istoriya [Herald of Saint Petersburg University. History] 67/1, 113–127.
Гуськов, Е.А. Преторианец Метилий Пудент и гражданская война в Риме. Вестник Санкт- Петербургского университета. История 67/1, 113–127.
Homo, L.P. 1951: Rome impériale et l’urbanisme dans l’antiquité. Paris.
Johnson, A. 1983: Roman Forts. London.
Kennedy, D.L. 1978: Some Observations on the Praetorian Guard. Ancient Society 9, 275–301.
Keppie, L. 1996: The Praetorian Guard before Sejanus. Athenaeum 84, 101–124.
Keppie, L. 1998: The Making of Roman Army: from Republic to Empire. London.
Killgrove, K. 2010: Migration and Mobility in Imperial Rome. PhD thesis. Chapel Hill.
Le Bohec, Y. 2001: Rimskaya armiya epokhi Ranney Imperii [The Roman Army of the Times of Early Empire]. Moscow.
Ле Боэк, Я. Римская армия эпохи Ранней Империи. М.
Lendon, J.E. 2006: Contubernalis, Commanipularis, and Commilito in Roman Soldiers’ Epigraphy: Drawing the Distinction. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 157, 270–276.
Letta, C. 1978: Le imagines Caesarum di un praefectus castrorum Aegypti e l’XI coorte pretoria. Athenaeum 56, 3–19.
Lommel van, K. 2013: The Terminology of the Medical Discharge and an Identity Shift among the Roman Disabled Veterans. Ancient History Bulletin 27, 65–74.
Machlayuk, A.V., Negin, A.E. 2018: Rimskie legiony. Samaya polnaya illyustrirovannaya entsiklopediya [Roman Legions. The Most Complete Illustrated Encyclopedia]. Moscow.
Махлаюк, А.В., Негин, А.Е. Римские легионы. Самая полная иллюстрированная энциклопедия. М.
Menéndez Argüín, A.R. 2006: Pretorianos: la guardia imperial de la Antigua Roma. Madrid.
Mommsen, Th. 1879: Die Gardetruppen der römischen Republik und der Kaiserzeit. Hermes 14/1, 25–35.
Morgan, G. 2006: 69 A.D.: The Year of Four Emperors. Oxford.
Ottley, S. 2009: The Role Played by the Praetorian Guard in the Events of AD 69, as Described by Tacitus in his Historiae. PhD thesis. Perth.
Pagnoni, A. 1942: Sul reclutamento degli ‘urbaniciani’. Epigraphica 4, 23–40.
Panciera, S. 1995: Una diciannovesima coorte pretoria? In: R. Frei-Stolba, M.A. Speidel (Hrsg.), Römische Inschriften. Neufunde, Neulesungen und Neuinterpretationen. Festschrift für Hans Lieb. (Arbeiten zur römischen Epigraphik und Altertumskunde, 2). Bâle, 113–121.
Parfenov, V.N. 1990: [On the Evaluation of Augustus’ Military Reforms]. Antichnyy mir i arkheologiya [Ancient World and Archaeology] 7, 65–76.
Парфенов, В.Н. К оценке военных реформ Августа. Античный мир и археология 7, 65–76.
Parfenov, V.N. 2001: Imperator Tsezar’ Avgust: Armiya. Voyna. Politika [Imperator Caesar Augustus: The Army. War. Politics]. Saint Petersburg.
Парфенов, В.Н. Император Цезарь Август: Армия. Война. Политика. СПб.
Passerini, A. 1939: Le coorti pretorie. Roma.
Pavón Torrejón, P. 2003: La cárcel y el encarcelamiento en el mundo romano. Madrid.
Platner, S.B., Ashby, Th. 1929: A Topographical Dictionary of Ancient Rome. London.
Pollard, N. 2006: The Roman Army. In: D.S. Potter (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Empire. Malden, 206–227.
Rankov, N.B. 1990: Frumentarii, the Castra Peregrina and the Provincial Officia. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 80, 176–182.
Rankov, N.B. 1994: The Praetorian Guard. London.
Redaelli, D. 2018: Militari ad Aquileia. Nuove note sull’epigrafe di C. Manlio Valeriano. Epigraphica 80/1–2, 223–246.
Redaelli, D. 2019: Nuove evidenze sui laterculi praetorianorum. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 209, 270–272.
Ricci, C. 2011: In custodiam Urbis: Notes on the Cohortes Urbanae (1968–2010). Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 60/4, 484–508.
Ricci, C. 2019: Caracalla e i pretoriani. Studi Classici e Orientali 65/1, 411–427.
Richmond, I.A. 1927: The Relation of the Praetorian Camp to Aurelian’s Wall of Rome. Papers of the British School at Rome 10, 12–22.
Roth, J. 1994: The Size and Organization of the Roman Imperial Legion. Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 43/3, 346–362.
Sablayrolles, R. 1996: Libertinus miles. Les cohortes de vigiles. Rome.
Sablayrolles, R. 2001: La rue, le pouvoir et le soldat: la garnison urbaine à Rome de César à Pertinax. In: La ville de Rome sous le Haut-Empire: nouvelles connaissances, nouvelles réflexions: colloque. (Pallas: Revue d’études antiques, 55). Rome, 127–154.
Sánchez Sanz, A. 2017: Pretorianos. La Elite del Ejército Romano. Madrid.
Šašel, J. 1972: Zur Rekrutierung der Prätorianer. Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 21/3, 474–480.
Scheidel, W. 1996: Measuring Sex, Age and Death in the Roman Empire: Explorations in Ancient Demography. Ann Arbor.
Scheidel, W. 2001: Roman Age Structure: Evidence and Models. Journal of Roman Studies 91, 1–26.
Sergeenko, M.E. 1964: Zhizn’ Drevnego Rima. Ocherki byta [Life of Ancient Rome. Essays on Everyday Life]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Сергеенко, М.Е. Жизнь Древнего Рима. Очерки быта. М.–Л.
Sinnigen, W.G. 1962: The Origins of the Frumentarii. Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome 27, 213–224.
Smith, R.E. 1972: The Army Reforms of Septimius Severus. Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 21/3, 481–500.
Southern, P. 2006: The Roman Army: A Social and Institutional History. Santa Barbara–Denver–Oxford.
Speidel, M.P. 1987: The Later Roman Field Army and the Guard of the High Empire. Latomus 46/2, 375–379.
Speidel, M.P. 1994: Riding for Caesar: The Horse Guards of the Roman Emperors. London.
Stein, E. 1922: Untersuchungen über das Officium der Prätorianerpräfektur seit Diokletian. Wien.
Syme, R. 1939: Les Cohortes Prétoriennes by Marcel Durry. Journal of Roman Studies 29/2, 242–248.
Syme, R. 1958: Tacitus. Vol. 1. Oxford.
Townend, G.B. 1964: Cluvius Rufus in the Histories of Tacitus. American Journal of Philology 85/4, 337–377.
Ushakov, Y.A. 1984: [The Role of the Praetorian Guard in the Internal Political Life of the Roman State under the First Emperors]. In: Antichnaya grazhdanskaya obshchina [The Ancient Civil Community]. Moscow, 115–131.
Ушаков, Ю.А. Роль преторианской гвардии во внутриполитической жизни Римского государства при первых императорах. В сб.: Античная гражданская община: Возникновение, структура, основные этапы. М., 115–131.
Ushakov, Y.A. 1986: [Praetorian Guard during the Civil War of 68–69 A.D.]. In: Antichnaya grazhdanskaya obshchina [The Ancient Civil Community]. Moscow, 78–93.
Ушаков, Ю.А. Преторианская гвардия в период гражданской войны 68–69 гг. н.э. В сб.: Античная гражданская община. M., 78–93.
Vincenti, V. 2006: Mosaici rinvenuti nei castra praetoria nel XIX secolo. In: C. Angelelli (ed.), Atti dell’ XI colloquio dell’ associazione italiana per lo studio e la conservazione del mosaico (Ancona, 16–19 febbraio 2005). Tivoli, 277–286.
Wardle, D. 1992: Cluvius Rufus and Suetonius. Hermes 120/4, 466–482.
Webster, G. 1998: The Roman Imperial Army of the First and Second Centuries A.D. 3rd ed. Norman.
Woods, R. 2007: Ancient and Early Modern Mortality: Experience and Understanding. The Economic History Review, New Series 60/2, 373–399.