Did the Early Historian Simonides of Ceos Ever Exist?
Surikov Igor E.
The Byzantine lexicon Suda in one of its entries mentions Simonides of Ceos, a historian and genealogist, who was, according to this sole testimony about him, a grandson of the lyric poet of the same name and lived in the fifth century BC, before the Peloponnesian War. This writer is usually believed to be a real person. F. Jacoby in the Fragmente der griechischen Historiker ascribes to him seven fragments, two with certainty and five as ‘questionable and doubtful’. R. Fowler in the Early Greek Mythography considers Simonides the grandson to be the author of only two fragments, but still does not deny his historicity, although he agrees that there are some incongruities in the evidence (one of the fragments is of Euhemeristic character, in another fragment peacocks appear as poultry – things that are more usual in the Hellenistic period). The article analyzes all seven fragments and makes an attempt to prove that the fifth century BC mythographer Simonides, the poet’s grandson, never existed; some of the fragments ascribed to him by Jacoby should be attributed to the lyricist, while others – to the little-known Hellenistic author Simonides the Younger (whose grandfather of course could not be the poet) mentioned in Pliny’s Natural History. Some other examples of abundant gross errors in Suda’s entries on early Greek historians are also cited in the article.
References:
Bakker, E.J. 2002: The Making of History: Herodotus’ Historiēs Apodexis. In: E.J. Bakker, I.J.F de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.), Brill’s Companion to Herodotus. Leiden–Boston–Köln, 3–32.
Bivar, A.D.H. 1998: [Plato and Mithraism]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 3–18.
Бивар, А.Д.Х. Платон и митраизм. ВДИ 2, 3–18.
Boedeker, D. 2001: Heroic Historiography: Simonides and Herodotus on Plataea. In: D. Boedeker, D. Sider (eds.), The New Simonides: Contexts of Praise and Desire. Oxford, 120–134.
Boedeker, D. 2021: Simonides of Ceos. In: C. Baron (ed.), The Herodotus Encyclopedia. Vol. III. P–Z. Hoboken, 1333–1334.
Boedeker, D., Sider, D. (eds.) 2001: The New Simonides: Contexts of Praise and Desire. Oxford.
Bravi, L. 2019: Simonides of Ceos and Epigram in Classical Greece. In: Chr. Henriksén (ed.), A Companion to Ancient Epigram. Hoboken, 249–263.
Flower, M.A. 1998a: Agesilaus of Sparta and the Origins of the Ruler Cult. Classical Quarterly 38/1, 123–134.
Flower, M.A. 1998b: Simonides, Ephorus, and Herodotus on the Battle of Thermopylae. Classical Quarterly 48/2, 365–379.
Fowler, R.L. 2007: Early Greek Mythography. Vol. I. Texts and Introduction. Oxford.
Fowler, R.L. 2013: Early Greek Mythography. Vol. II. Commentary. Oxford.
Jacoby, F. 1949: Atthis: The Local Chronicles of Ancient Athens. Oxford.
Jacoby, F. (Hrsg.) 1958: Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (FGrHist). Teil 3. Geschichte von Staedten und Voelkern (Horographie und Ethnographie). C. Autoren ueber einzelne Laender. Bd.I. Aegypten – Geten. Leiden.
Jacoby, F. (Hrsg.) 1962: Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (FGrHist). Teil 2. Zeitgeschichte. B. Spezialgeschichten, Autobiographien und Memoiren, Zeittafeln. Nachdruck. Leiden.
Jacoby, F. (Hrsg.) 1995a: Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (FGrHist). Teil 1. Genealogie und Mythographie. A. Vorrede. Text. Addenda. Konkordanz. Nachdruck des Neudruckes von 1957. Leiden–New York–Köln.
Jacoby, F. (Hrsg.) 1995b: Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (FGrHist). Teil 1. Genealogie und Mythographie. a. Kommentar. Nachträge. Nachdruck des Neudruckes von 1957. Leiden–New York–Köln.
Kowerski, L.M. 2005: Simonides on the Persian Wars: A Study of the Elegiac Verses of the “New Simonides”. New York–London.
Lendle, O. 1992: Einführung in die griechische Geschichtsschreibung von Hekataios bis Zosimos. Darmstadt.
Luce, T.J. 1997: The Greek Historians. London–New York.
Marincola, J. (ed.) 2007: A Companion to Greek and Roman Historiography. Vol. I–II. Oxford.
Matijašić, I. 2018: Shaping the Canons of Ancient Greek Historiography. Imitation, Classicism, and Literary Criticism. Berlin–Boston.
Mehl, A. 2004: Herodotus and Xanthus of Sardis Compared. In: V. Karageorghis, I. Taifacos (eds.), The World of Herodotus. Proceedings of an International Conference held at the Foundation Anastasios G. Leventis, Nicosia, September 2003 and organized by the Foundation Anastasios G. Leventis and the Faculty of Letters, University of Cyprus. Nicosia, 337–348.
Momigliano, A. 1990: The Classical Foundations of Modern Historiography. Berkeley.
Muccioli, F. 2005: Gli onori divini per Lisandro a Samo. A proposito di Plutarchus, Lysander 18. In: L. de Blois, J. Bons, T. Kessels, D.M. Schenkeveld (eds.), The Statesman in Plutarch’s Works: Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Plutarch Society. Vol. II. The Statesman in Plutarch’s Greek and Roman Lives. Leiden–Boston, 199–213.
Nails, D. 2002: The People of Plato: A Prosopography of Plato and Other Socratics. Indianapolis.
Paradiso, A. 2007: Simonides (ὁ γενεαλόγος). In: I. Worthington (ed.), Jacoby Online. URL: https://scholarlyeditions.brill.com/bnjo/; accessed on: 26.04.2023.
Passa, E. 2019: Empedocles in the West, Panyassis in the East: Doric and Hexameter Poetry in the Classical Age. In: E. Passa, O. Tribulato (eds.), The Paths of Greek: Literature, Linguistics and Epigraphy. Studies in Honour of Albio Cesare Cassio. Berlin–Boston, 107–124.
Pearson, L. 1975: Early Ionian Historians. Reprint of the 1939 ed. Westport.
Pelliccia, H. 1992: Sappho 16, Gorgias’ Helen, and the Preface to Herodotus’ Histories. In: F.M. Dunn, T. Cole (eds.), Beginnings in Classical Literature. Cambridge, 63–84.
Pitcher, L. 2009: Writing Ancient History: An Introduction to Classical Historiography. London–New York.
Poltera, O. 1998: Von Seleukos to Simonides und zurück: Simon. PMG 540. Museum Helveticum 55/3, 129–130.
Rawles, R. 2018: Simonides on Tombs, and the ‘Tomb of Simonides’. In: N. Goldschmidt, B. Graziosi (eds.), Tombs of the Ancient Poets: Between Literary Reception and Material Culture. Oxford–New York, 51–68.
Scanlon, T.F. 2015: Greek Historiography. Oxford.
Shichalin, Y.A. 1999: Antichnost’ – Evropa – istoriya [Antiquity – Europe – History]. Moscow.
Шичалин, Ю.А. Античность – Европа – история. М.
Shipley, G. 2011: Pseudo-Skylax’s Periplous: The Circumnavigation of the Inhabited World. Text, Translation and Commentary. Bristol.
Surikov, I.E. 2021a: [Towards the Chronology of the Life and Work of the Historian Hellanicus]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 81/4, 837–862.
Суриков, И.Е. К хронологии жизни и творчества историка Гелланика. ВДИ 81/4, 837–862.
Surikov, I.E. 2021b: [Forgotten Historian, Dionysius of Miletus]. Metamorfozy istorii [Metamorphoses of History] 20, 22–35.
Суриков, И.Е. Забытый историк Дионисий Милетский. Метаморфозы истории 20, 22–35.
Vannicelli, P. 2007: To Each his Own: Simonides and Herodotus on Thermopylae. In: J. Marincola (ed.), A Companion to Greek and Roman Historiography. Vol. II. Oxford, 315–321.
Vasilev, M.I. 2016: The Date of Herodotus’ Visit to Macedonia. Ancient West and East 15, 31–51.
Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, U. von 1913: Sappho und Simonides: Untersuchungen über griechische Lyriker. Berlin.
Winiarczyk, M. 2013: The Sacred History of Euhemerus of Messene. Berlin–Boston.