An Unpublished North West Semitic Inscription from the Collection of the Russian Archaeological Institute in Constantinople
Балахванцев Арчил Савелич, Коган Леонид Ефимович, Лявданский Алексей Кимович, Тункина Ирина Владимировна
Cтатья представляет собой публикацию эстампажа ранее неизвестной северозападносемитской алфавитной надписи из коллекции Русского археологического института в Константинополе. В настоящее время эстампаж хранится в Санкт-Петербургском филиале Архива РАН. Надпись, с которой был сделан эстампаж, была выполнена в технике барельефа, предположительно, на большом сосуде с орнаментом. Палеографический анализ показал, что надпись с большой вероятностью датируется серединой IX в. до н. э. и происходит из Южного Ханаана (Палестины). Языковые особенности памятника также в основном подтверждают его южноханаанское происхождение.
Библиография:
Abou-Assaf, A., Bordreuil, P., Millard, A. 1982: La statue de Tell Fekherye et son inscription bilingue assyro-arameenne. Paris.
Aharoni, Y. 1981: Arad Inscriptions. Jerusalem.
Aḥituv, Sh., Mazar, A. 2014: The inscriptions from Tel Reḥov and their contribution to the study of script and writing during Iron Age IIA. In: E. Eshel, Y. Levin (eds.), “See, I Will Bring A Scroll Recounting What Befell Me” (Ps 40:8). Epigraphy and Daily Life from the Bible to the Talmud Dedicated to the Memory of Professor Hanan Eshel. Gottingen, 39–68.
Al-Ghabban, A.I., Andre-Salvini, B., Demange, F., Juvin, C., Cotty, M. (eds.) 2010: Roads of Arabia. Archaeology and History of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Paris.
Athas, G. 2003: The Tel Dan Inscription. A Reappraisal and a New Interpretation. Sheffield.
Avigad, N. 1953: The epitaph of a Royal Steward from Siloam Village. Israel Exploration Journal 3, 137–152.
Avigad, N., Sass, B. 1997: Corpus of West Semitic Stamp Seals. Jerusalem.
Balakhvantsev, A.S. 2016: The absolute chronology of Archaic Scythia: eastern benchmarks. In: A. S. Balakhvantsev, S. V. Kullanda (eds.), Kavkaz i step’ na rubezhe epokhi pozdney bronzy i rannego zheleza: materialy mezhdunzrodnoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy pamyati Marii Nikolayevny Pogrebovoy [Caucasus and Steppes in the Late Bronze – Early Iron Age: Proceedings of the International Conference Dedicated to the Memory of Maria Nikolaevna Pogrebova]. Moscow, 15–24.
Балахванцев, А. С. Абсолютная хронология архаической Скифии: восточные реперы. В сб.: А. С. Балахванцев, С. В. Кулланда (ред.), Кавказ и степь на рубеже эпохи поздней бронзы и раннего железа: материалы международной научной конференции, посвященной памяти Ма‑ рии Николаевны Погребовой. М., 15–24.
Basargina, Ye. Yu. 1995: [Russian Archaeological Institute in Constantinople: the archival collections]. In: I. P. Medvedev (ed.), Arkhivy russkikh vizantinistov v Sankt-Peterburge [Archives of Russian Byzantinists in Saint Petersburg]. Saint Petersburg, 62–92.
Басаргина, Е. Ю. Русский археологический институт в Константинополе: архивные фонды. В сб.: И. П. Медведев (ред.), Архивы русских византинистов в Санкт-Петербурге. СПб., 62–92.
Biran, A., Naveh, J. 1995: The Tel Dan inscription: a new fragment. Israel Exploration Journal 45, 1–18.
Bordreuil, P. 1977: Une inscription phenicienne champlevee des environs de Byblos. Semitica 27, 23–27.
Cross, F.M. 2003: Leaves from an Epigrapher’s Notebook: Collected Papers in Hebrew and West Semitic Palaeography and Epigraphy. Winona Lake.
Cross, F.M., McCarter, K.P. 1973: Two archaic inscriptions on clay objects from Byblos. Rivista di Studi Fenici 1, 3–8.
Dearman, J.A. (ed.) 1989: Studies in the Mesha Inscription and Moab. Atlanta.
Demsky, A. 1986: The ʻIzbet Ṣarṭah ostracon – ten years later. In: I. Finkelstein (ed.), ʻIzbet Ṣarṭah. An Early Iron Age Site near Rosh Haʻayin, Israel. Oxford, 186–197.
Deutsch, R., Heltzer, M. 1999: West Semitic Epigraphic News of the 1st Millennium BCE. Tel Aviv.
Deutsch, R., Lemaire, A. 2000: Biblical Period Personal Seals in the Shlomo Moussaieff Collection. Tel Aviv.
Dobbs-Allsopp, F., Roberts, J., Seow, C., Whitaker, R. 2005: Hebrew Inscriptions: Texts from the Biblical Period of the Monarchy with Concordance. New Haven–London.
Dupont-Sommer, A., Starcky, J. 1958: Les inscriptions arameennes de Sfire (steles I et II). Paris.
Eshel, E., Notarius, T., Dagan, A., Eniukhina, M., Workman, V., Maeir, A. 2022: Two Iron Age alphabetic inscriptions from Tell eṣ-Ṣafi/Gath, Israel. Bulletin of the American Schools for the Oriental Research 388, online first (no page numbers).
Finkelstein, I., Sass, B., Singer-Avitz, L. 2008: Writing in Iron IIA Philistia in the light of the Tēl Zayit/ Zētā abecedary. Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palastina-Vereins 124, 1–14.
Garr, R. 1985: Dialect Geography of Syria-Palestine. 1000–586 B.C.E. Winona Lake.
Gesenius, W. 1910: Hebrew Grammar. Oxford.
Gogel, S. 1988: A Grammar of Epigraphic Hebrew. Atlanta.
Hamilton, G. 2014: Reconceptualizing the periods of early alphabetic scripts. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 30–55.
Heide, M. 2012: The Moabitica and their aftermath. How to handle a forgery affair with an international impact. In: E. Lubetski, M. Lubetski (eds.), New Inscriptions and Seals Relating to the Biblical World. Atlanta, 193–241.
Herr, L. 2014: Aramaic and Ammonite seal scripts. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 175–186.
Lemaire, A., Sass, B. 2013: The mortuary stele with Sam’alian inscription from Ordekburnu near Zincirli. Bulletin of the American Schools for Oriental Research 369, 57–136.
Maeir, A., Eshel, E. 2014: Four short alphabetic inscriptions from Late Iron Age IIa Tell eṣ-Ṣafi/Gath and their implications for the development of literacy in Iron Age Philistial and Environs. In: E. Eshel, Y. Levin (eds.), “See, I Will Bring A Scroll Recounting What Befell Me” (Ps 40:8). Epigraphy and Daily Life from the Bible to the Talmud Dedicated to the Memory of Professor Hanan Eshel. Gottingen, 69–88, 205–210.
Maeir, M., Wimmer, S., Zukerman, A., Demsky, A. 2008: A late Iron Age I / early Iron Age II Old Canaanite inscription from Tell eṣ-Ṣafī/Gath, Israel: palaeography, dating, and historical-cultural significance. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 351, 39–71.
Mazar, A. 2003: Three 10th–9th century BCE inscriptions from Tel Rehov. In: C. den Hertog, U. Hubner, S. Munger (eds.), Saxa loquentur. Studien zur Archaologie Palastinas/Israels. Festschrift fur Volkmar Fritz zum 65. Geburtstag. Munster, 171–184.
Mazar, E., Ben-Shlomo, D., Aḥituv, S. 2013: An inscribed pithos from the Ophel, Jerusalem. Israel Exploration Journal 63, 39–49.
McCarter, K.P. 1975: The Antiquity of the Greek Alphabet and the Early Phoenician Scripts. Missoula.
McCarter, K.P. 2008: Paleographic notes on the Tel Zayit abecedary. In: R. Tappy, P. K. McCarter (eds.), Literate Culture and Tenth-Century Canaan: The Tel Zayit Abecedary in Context. Winona Lake, 45–59.
McCarter, K.P., Bunimovitz, S., Lederman, Z. 2011: An archaic Baal inscription from Tel Beth- Shemesh. Tel Aviv 38, 179–193.
Meshel, Z. 2012: Kuntillet ʕAjrud (Ḥorvat Teman). An Iron Age II Religious Site on the Judah-Sinai Border. Jerusalem.
Millard, A. 1970: “Scriptio Continua” in early Hebrew: ancient practice or modern surmise? Journal of Semitic Studies 15, 2–15.
Moller, G. 1909: Hieratische Palaographie. Bd. I. Leipzig.
Naveh, J. 1973: Word division in West Semitic writing. Israel Exploration Journal 23, 206–208.
Naveh, J. 1982: Early History of the Alphabet. An Introduction to West Semitic Epigraphy and Palaeography. Jerusalem.
Osborne, J. 2020: The Syro-Anatolian City-States: An Iron Age Culture. New York.
Pardee, D. 2009: A new Aramaic inscription from Zincirli. Bulletin of the American Schools for Oriental Research 356, 51–71.
Pavlichenko, N.A. 2018: The squeezes of Greek inscriptions in the collection of the Russian Archaeological Institute in Constantinople]. In: I. V. Tunkina (ed.), Millerovskiye chteniya–2018: Preyemstvennost i traditsii v sokhranenii i izuchenii dokumentalnogo akademicheskogo naslediya. Materialy II Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii 24–26 maya 2018 g., Sankt-Peterburg [Muller Conference 2018. Continuity and Traditions in Preserving and Studying Documentary Academic Heritage. Materials of the 2nd International Scientific Conference. May 24–26, 2018, St. Petersburg]. Saint Petersburg, 465–473.
Павличенко, Н. А. Коллекция эстампажей греческих надписей в фонде Русского Архео‑ логического института в Константинополе. В сб.: И. В. Тункина (ред.), Миллеровские чте‑ ния–2018. Преемственность и традиции в сохранении и изучении документального акаде‑ мического наследия. Материалы II Международной научной конференции 24–26 мая 2018 г., Санкт-Петербург. СПб., 465–473.
Pilkington, N. 2019: The Carthaginian Empire: 550–202 BCE. New York.
Renz, J. 1995a: Die althebraischen Inschriften. Teil 1. Text und Kommentar (Handbuch der althebraischen Epigraphik, I). Darmstadt.
Renz, J. 1995b: Die althebraischen Inschriften. Texte und Tafeln (Handbuch der althebraischen Epigraphik, III). Darmstadt.
Renz, J. 1995c: Die althebraischen Inschriften. Teil 2. Zusammenfassende Erortungen, Palaographie und Glossar (Handbuch der althebraischen Epigraphik, II/1). Darmstadt.
Roche, M.-J. 2020: Inscriptions en champleve de Taymā’. Semitica 62, 163–205.
Rollston, C. 2003: Non-provenanced epigraphs I: pillaged antiquities, Northwest Semitic forgeries, and protocols for laboratory tests. Maarav 10, 135–193.
Rollston, C. 2004: Non-provenanced epigraphs II: the status of non-provenanced epigraphs within the broader corpus of Northwest Semitic. Maarav 11, 57–79.
Rollston, C. 2008: The Phoenician script of the Tel Zayit abecedary and putative evidence for Israelite literacy. In: R. Tappy, P. K. McCarter (eds.), Literate Culture and Tenth-Century Canaan: The Tel Zayit Abecedary in Context. Winona Lake, 61–96.
Rollston, C. 2014a: The Iron Age Phoenician script. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 72–99.
Rollston, C. 2014b: Northwest Semitic cursive scripts of Iron II. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 202–234.
Sass, B. 2017: The emergence of monumental West Semitic alphabetic writing with an emphasis on Byblos. Semitica 59, 109–141.
Sass, B., Garfinkel, Y., Hasel, M., Klingbeil, M. 2015: The Lachish jar sherd: an early alphabetic inscription discovered in 2014. Bulletin of the American Schools for the Oriental Research 374, 233–245.
Schmitz, P.C. 2008: Deity and royalty in dedicatory formulae: the Ekron store-jar inscription viewed in the light of Judges 7:18, 20 and the inscribed gold medallion from the Douimes necropolis at Carthage (KAI 73). Maarav 15/2, 165–173.
Schmitz, P.C. 2014: Phoenician seal script. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 141–174.
Schniedewind, W. 2005: Problems in the paleographic dating of inscriptions. In: T. Levy, T. Higham (eds.), The Bible and Radiocarbon Dating: Archaeology, Text and Science. Oakville, 405–412.
Sebbane, M. 2016. ḥnn gaming board: two-sided gaming board fragment bearing an ownership inscription. In: S. Bunimovitz, Z. Lederman (eds.), Tel Beth-Shemesh: A Border Community in Judah: Renewed excavations 1990–2000: The Iron Age. Tel Aviv, 639–646.
Smith, M., Pitard, W. 2009: The Ugaritic Baal Cycle. Vol. II. Introduction with Text, Translation and Commentary of KTU/CAT 1.3–1.4. Leiden.
Stager, L. 1969: An inscribed potsherd from the eleventh century. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 194, 45–52.
Tappy, R., McCarter, P.K., Lundberg, M., Zuckerman, B. 2006: An abecedary of the mid-tenth century from the Judean Shephelah. Bulletin of the American Schools for Oriental Research 344, 5–46.
Tropper, J. 1993: Die Inschriften von Zincirli. Neue Edition und vergleichende Grammatik des phonizischen, samʾalischen und aramaischen Textkorpus. Munster.
Tropper, J. 2012: Ugaritische Grammatik. Munster.
Tunkina, I. V., Bondar, L. D., Ponikarovskaya, M. V., Pavlichenko, N. A., Chernova N. V. 2020: [The squeezes of the Russian Archaeological Institute in Constantinople (1895–1914) in the collection of the St. Petersburg Branch of the Archive of the Russian Academy of Sciences: scientific restoration, comprehensive study, creation of high-precision digital 3D models]. Peterburgskiy istoricheskiy zhurnal [Saint-Petersburg Historical Journal] 4 (28), 194–203.
Тункина И. В., Бондарь Л. Д., Поникаровская М. В., Павличенко Н. А., Чернова Н. В. Эстам‑ пажи Русского археологического института в Константинополе (1895–1914) в собрании Санкт-Петербургского филиала Архива РАН: Научная реставрация, комплексное изуче‑ ние, создание высокоточных цифровых 3D‑моделей. Петербургский исторический журнал. 2020. № 4 (28). С. 194–203.
Vanderhooft, D. 2014: Iron Age Moabite, Hebrew, and Edomite monumental scripts. In: J. A. Hackett, W. Aufrecht (eds.), “An Eye for Form”: Epigraphic Essays in Honor of Frank Moore Cross. Winona Lake, 107–126.
Wimmer, S. 2008: Palastinisches Hieratisch: die Zahl- und Sonderzeichen in der althebraischen Schrift. Wiesbaden.