Современные исследования Адрианова вала: проблемы и поиски
Барышников Антон Ералыевич, Данилочкина Ксения Сергеевна
В статье рассматривается современная историография одного из наиболее известных памятников римской Британии – Адрианова вала. В ее развитии можно выделить два основных направления – увеличение корпуса источников в ходе постоянных археологических исследований и концептуальное переосмысление истории римского лимеса в Британии. Авторы обращают внимание на некоторые дискуссионные темы, занимающие важное место в новейших публикациях, в частности на споры об обстоятельствах сооружения и предназначении Адрианова вала. Отдельно рассматриваются попытки реконструировать социокультурную историю пограничных территорий и идентичности его обитателей.
Библиография:
Baryshnikov, A.E. 2012: [Roman Britain and the problem of romanization: crisis of a traditional concept and the discussion about new approaches in contemporary British scholarship]. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N. I. Lobachevskogo [Bulletin of Lobachevsky University of Nizhni Novgorod] 6/3, 200–211.
Барышников, А. Е. Римская Британия и проблема романизации: кризис традиционной концепции и дискуссия о новых подходах в современном английском антиковедении. Вестник Нижегородского университета им. Н. И. Лобачевского 6/3, 200–211.
Bidwell, P. 2005: The system of obstacles on Hadrian’s Wall: their extent, date and purpose. Arbeia Journal 8, 53–76.
Bidwell, P. 2008: Did Hadrian’s Wall have a wall-walk? In: P. Bidwell (ed.), Understanding Hadrian’s Wall: Papers from a Conference Held at South Shields, 3rd-5th November 2006. Kendal, 129–143.
Birley, A.R. 2002a: Fifty years of Roman frontier studies. In: P. Freeman, J. Bennett, Z. T. Fiema, B. Hoffmann (eds.), Limes XVIII: Proceedings of the XVIII th International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies, held in Amman, Jordan (September 2000). Vol. I. (BAR International Series, 1084). Oxford, 1–11.
Birley, A.R. 2002b: Garrison Life at Vindolanda: A Band of Brothers. Stroud.
Birley, R. 2009: Vindolanda: Everyday Life on Rome’s Northern Frontier. Stroud.
Bowman, A.K. 1994: Life and Letters on the Roman Frontier: Vindolanda and Its People. New York.
Bowman, A.K., Thomas, J.D., Tomlin, R.S.O. 2010: The Vindolanda writing-tablets (Tabulae Vindolandenses IV, pt. 1). Britannia 41, 187–224.
Bowman, A.K., Thomas, J.D., Tomlin, R.S.O. 2011: The Vindolanda writing-tablets (Tabulae Vindolandenses IV, pt. 2). Britannia 42, 113–144.
Bowman, A.K., Thomas, J.D., Tomlin, R.S.O. 2019: The Vindolanda writing-tablets (Tabulae Vindolandenses IV, pt. 3): new letters of Iulius Verecundus. Britannia 50, 225–251.
Breeze, D.J. 2006: J. Collingwood Bruce’s Handbook to the Roman Wall. Newcastle upon Tyne.
Breeze, D.J. 2011: The Frontiers of Imperial Rome. Barnsley.
Breeze, D.J. 2014: Hadrian’s Wall: A History of Archaeological Thought. Kendal.
Breeze, D.J. 2015: The vallum of Hadrian’s Wall. Archaeologia Aeliana. Series 5. 44, 1–30.
Breeze, D.J. 2017: The placing of the forts on Hadrian’s Wall. Archaeologia Aeliana. Series 5. 46, 21–39.
Breeze, D.J. 2018: The value of studying Roman frontiers. Theoretical Roman Archaeology Journal 1. URL: https://traj.openlibhums.org/article/id/3995/; дата обращения: 06.04.2021.
Breeze, D.J., Dobson, B. 2000: Hadrian’s Wall. London.
Breeze, D.J., Ferris, I. 2016: They think it’s all over. The face of victory on the British frontier. Journal of Conflict Archaeology 11/1, 19–39.
Buck, T., Greene, E.M., Meyer, A., Barlow, V., Graham, E. 2019: The body in the ditch: alternative funerary practices on the northern frontier of the Roman Empire? Britannia 50, 203–224.
Cherry, D. 1998: Frontier and Society in Roman North Africa. Oxford.
Collins, R. 2006: Late Roman frontier communities in Northern Britain: A theoretical context for the ‘end’ of Hadrian’s Wall. In: B. Croxford, H. Goodchild, J. Lucas, N. Ray (eds.), TRAC 2005: Proceedings of the Fifteenth Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference, Birmingham 2005. Oxford, 1–11.
Collins, R. 2008: Identity in the frontier: theory and multiple community interfacing. In: C. Fenwick, M. Wiggins, D. Wythe (eds.), TRAC 2007: Proceedings of the Seventeenth Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference, London 2007. Oxford, 45–52.
Collins, R. 2012: Hadrian’s Wall and the End of Empire. The Roman Frontier in the 4th and 5 th Centuries. London–New York.
Collins, R., McIntosh, F. (eds.) 2014: Life in the Limes: Studies of the People and Objects of the Roman Frontiers Presented to Lindsay Allason-Jones on the Occasion of her Birthday and Retirement. Oxford.
Collins, R., Symonds, M. (eds.) 2013: Breaking down Boundaries: Hadrian’s Wall in the 21st Century. Portsmouth.
Collins, R., Symonds, M. (eds.) 2019: Hadrian’s Wall 2009–2019. A Summary of Excavation and Research prepared for the Fourteenth Pilgrimage of Hadrian’s Wall, 20–28 July 2019. Kendal.
Crow, J.G. 1991: A review of current research on the turrets and curtain of Hadrian’s Wall. Britannia 22, 51–63.
Daniels, C. 1979: Fact and theory on Hadrian’s Wall. Britannia 10, 357–364.
DeLaine, J. 2002: The Temple of Hadrian and Cyzicus and Roman attitudes to exceptional construction. Papers of the British School at Rome 70, 205–230.
Driessen, M. 2005: Monumentality for Roman Nijmegen. In: Z. Visy (ed.), Limes XIX. Proceedings of the XIX th International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies Held in Pécs, Hungary, September 2003. Pécs, 315–322.
Dyson, S.L. 1985: The Creation of the Roman Frontier. Princeton.
Eckardt, H. 2014: Objects and Identities: Roman Britain and the North-Western Provinces. Oxford.
Eckardt, H., Müldner, G., Speed, G. 2015: The late Roman field army in Northern Britain? Mobility, material culture and multi-isotope analysis at Scorton (N Yorks). Britannia 46, 191–223.
Everitt, A. 2009: Hadrian and the Triumph of Rome. New York.
Fieber, K.D., Mills, J.P., Peppa, M.V., Haynes, I., Turner, S., Turner, A., Douglas, M., Bryan, P.G. 2017: Cultural heritage through time: A case study at Hadrian’s Wall, United Kingdom. International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences. Vol. XLII-2/W3, 297–302.
Frere, S. 1991: Britannia: A History of Roman Britain. London.
Gardner, A. 2007a: An Archaeology of Identity: Soldiers and Society in Late Roman Britain. London– New York.
Gardner, A. 2007b: Fluid frontiers: cultural interaction on the edge of empire. Stanford Journal of Archaeology 5, 43–60.
Gardner, A. 2017a: Brexit, boundaries and imperial identities: a comparative view. Journal of Social Archaeology 17/1, 3–26.
Gardner, A. 2017b: Roman Britain from the outside: comparing western and northern frontier cultures. In: S. Gonzalez Sanchez, A. Guglielmi (eds.), Romans and Barbarians beyond the Frontiers: Archaeology, Ideology and Identities in the North. (Themes in Roman Archaeology, 1). Oxford, 34–47.
Gardner, A. 2018: Power, knowledge and the past. Antiquity 92 (366), 1662–1664.
Goldsworthy, A. 2018: Hadrian’s Wall: Rome and the Limits of Empire. London.
Graafstal, E. 2018: What happened in the Summer of AD122? Hadrian on the British frontier – archaeology, epigraphy and historical agency. Britannia 49, 79–111.
Hanson, W.S. 2014: The nature and function of Roman frontiers revisited. In: R. Collins, F. McIntosh (eds.), Life in the Limes: Studies of the People and Objects of the Roman Frontiers Presented to Lindsay Allason-Jones on the Occasion of her Birthday and Retirement. Oxford, 4–10.
Hill, P.R. 2003: The Construction of Hadrian’s Wall. Doctoral thesis, Durham University. URL: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/1071/; дата обращения: 06.04.2021.
Hill, P.R. 2006: The Construction of Hadrian’s Wall. Stroud.
Hingley, R. 2008: Hadrian’s Wall in theory: pursuing new agendas? In: P. Bidwell (ed.), Understanding Hadrian’s Wall: Papers from a Conference Held at South Shields, 3rd –5th November 2006. Kendal, 25–28.
Hingley, R. 2010: Tales of the frontier: diasporas on Hadrian’s Wall. In: H. Eckardt (ed.), Roman Diasporas: Archaeological Approaches to Mobility and Diversity in the Roman Empire. Portsmouth, 227–243.
Hingley, R. 2012: Hadrian’s Wall: A Life. Oxford.
Hingley, R., Hartis, R. 2011: Contextualizing Hadrian’s Wall: the wall as ‘debatable lands’. In: O. Hekster, T. Kaizer (eds.), Frontiers in the Roman World: Proceedings of the Ninth Workshop of the International Network Impact of Empire (Durham, 16–19 April 2009). Leiden, 79–96.
Hodgson, N. 2017: Hadrian’s Wall. Archaeology at the Limit of Rome’s Empire. Ramsbury.
Hunter, F. 2016: Beyond Hadrian’s Wall. In: M. Millett, L. Revell, A. Moore (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Roman Britain. Oxford, 179–202.
James, S. 2013: Rome and the Sword. London.
Kurchin, B. 1995: Romans and Britons on the northern frontier: a theoretical evaluation of the archaeology of resistance. In: P. Rush (ed.), Theoretical Roman Archaeology: Second Conference Proceedings. Aldershot, 124–131.
Mattingly, D. 2004: Being Roman: expressing identity in a provincial setting. Journal of Roman Archaeology 17, 5–25.
Mattingly, D. 2006: An Imperial Possession. Britain in the Roman Empire, 54 BC – AD 409. London.
Mattingly, D. 2011: Imperialism, Power and Identity: Experiencing the Roman Empire. Princeton–Oxford.
Nesbitt, C. 2016: Multiculturalism on Hadrian’s Wall. In: M. Millett, L. Revell, A. Moore (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Roman Britain. Oxford, 224–244.
Nesbitt, C., Tolia-Kelly, D.P. 2009: Hadrian’s Wall: Embodied archaeologies of the linear monument. Journal of Social Archaeology 9/3, 368–390.
Noy, D. 2010: Epigraphic evidence for immigrants at Rome and in Roman Britain. In: H. Eckardt (ed.), Roman Diasporas: Archaeological Approaches to Mobility and Diversity in the Roman Empire. Portsmouth, 13–26.
Olusoga, D. 2016: Black and British: A Forgotten History. London.
Pitts, M., Versluys, M.J. (eds.) 2014: Globalisation and the Roman World: World History, Connectivity, and Material Culture. Cambridge.
Robertson, A.S. 1979: The Antonine Wall. A Handbook to the Roman Wall between Forth and Clyde and a Guide to its Surviving Remains. Glasgow.
Sadovskaya, M.S. 1988: [Roman fort at Vindolanda. To the question of romanization of Britain in the first century A.D.]. In: V. M. Strogetskiy (ed.), Iz istorii antichnogo obshchestva [From the History of Ancient Society], 71–81.
Садовская, М. С. Римский форт Виндоланда. К вопросу о романизации Британии в I в. н. э. В сб.: В. М. Строгецкий (ред.), Из истории античного общества. Горький, 71–81.
Sargent, A. 2002: The North-South divide revisited: Thoughts on the character of Roman Britain. Britannia 33, 219–226.
Shotter, D. 1996: The Roman Frontier in Britain: Hadrian’s Wall, the Antonine Wall and Roman Policy in the North. Preston.
Sommer, S. 2015: No way to go? Gates and gaps in the Raetian Wall. In: D. J. Breeze, R. H. Jones, I. A. Oltean (eds.), Understanding Roman Frontiers. A Celebration for Professor Bill Hanson. Edinburgh, 37–53.
Southern, P. 2016: Hadrian’s Wall. Everyday Life on a Roman Frontier. Stroud.
Symonds, M.F.A., Mason, D.J.P. (eds.) 2009: Frontiers of Knowledge: A Research Framework for Hadrian’s Wall, Part of the Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Site. Vol. I–II. Durham.
Tomlin, R.S.O. 2018: Britannia Romana: Roman Inscriptions and Roman Britain. Oxford.
Welfare, H.G. 2013: A Roman camp, quarries, and the vallum at Shield-on-the-Wall (Newbrough). Archaelogia Aeliana. Ser. 5.42, 81–99.
Whittaker, C.R. 1994: Frontiers of the Roman Empire: A Social and Economic Study. Baltimore–London.
Whittaker, C.R. 2004: Rome and Its Frontiers: The Dynamics of Empire. London–New York.
Wilmott, T. (ed.) 2009: Hadrian’s Wall: Archaeological Research by English Heritage 1976–2000. London.
Witcher, R. 2010a: The fabulous tales of the common people, part 1: representing Hadrian’s Wall. Public Archaeology 9/3, 126–152.
Witcher, R. 2010b: The fabulous tales of the common people, part 2: encountering Hadrian’s Wall. Public Archaeology 9/4, 211–238.
Witcher, R., Tolia-Kelly, D.P., Hingley, R. 2010: Archaeologies of landscape: excavating the materialities of Hadrian’s Wall. Journal of Material Culture 15/1, 105–128.