The Hellenes of the Emperor Julian: The Problem of Cultural Self-Identity Among Late Antique Intellectuals
Miroshnichenko Evgenii I.
The article investigates the ideology of the group of Late Antique intellectuals centred around the Emperor Julian in the early 360s. These intellectuals were practitioners of the traditional paideia and called themselves Hellenes. The author analyzes the crisis of selfidentity among the members of this community on the example of such representatives as Libanius, Himerius and Julian himself. The problem of correlation between religious and cultural elements in the ‘hellenic’ identity is studied in the context of the rising Christianity and on the example of Gregory Nazianzinus polemical orations against Julian. The author concludes that the ideology of ‘Hellenism’ was destroyed by the internal conflict between a serious attitude to religion and the spread of metaphorical interpretation. This conflict caused the separation of religious elements of ‘Hellenism’ from the literary and rhetorical ones. Christian intellectuals such as Gregory and Basil the Great used this tension to ‘appropriate’ the classical paideia, which resulted in the gradual Christianization of ‘Hellenism’.
References:
Athanassiadi-Fowden, P. 1981: Julian and Hellenism. An Intellectual Biography. Oxford.
Barnes, T.D. 1987: Himerius and the fourth century. In: Classical Philology 82/3, 206–225.
Becker, M. (ed.) 2013: Eunapios aus Sardes. Biographien über Philosophen und Sophisten. Stuttgart.
Bernardi, J. (ed.) 1983: Grégoire de Nazianze. Discours 4–5. Contre Julien. Paris.
Bidez, J., Lacombrade, C., Rochefort, G. (eds.) 1932–1964: Julien. OEuvres Complètes. 2 vols. Paris.
Bouffartigue, J. 1991: Julien ou l’hellénisme décomposé. In: S. Saїd (ed.), ἙΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ. Quelques jalons pour une histoire de l’identité grecque. Actes du Colloque de Strasburg 25–27 octobre. Leiden, 251–266.
Bouffartigue, J. 2016: Saloustios. In: R. Goulet (ed.), Dictionnaire des philosophes antiques. Vol. 6. Paris, 91–95.
Bowersock, G. 1978: Julian the Apostate. London.
Bowersock, G. 1990: Hellenism in Late Antiquity. Ann Arbor.
Bowie, E.L. 1991: Hellenes and Hellenism in writers of the early 2nd Sophistic. In: S. Saїd (ed.), ἙΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ. Quelques jalons pour une histoire de l’identité grecque. Actes du Colloque de Strasburg 25–27 octobre. Leiden, 183–204.
Boulanger, F. (éd.) 2012: Basile de Césarée. Aux jeunes gens: sur la manière de tirer profit des lettres hellénique. Paris.
Browning, R. 1975: The Emperor Julian. London.
Clark, E.A. 1992: The Origenist Controversy: The Cultural Construction of an Early Christian Debate. Princeton.
Colonna, A. (ed.) 1951: Himerius. Declamationes et Orationes. Roma.
Cribiore, R. 2013: Libanius the Sophist. Rhetoric, Reality and Religion in the Fourth Century. London.
Dawson, D. 1992: Allegorical Readers and Cultural Revision in Ancient Alexandria. Berkeley.
Edwards, M. 2004: Pagan and Christian monotheism in the Age of Constantine. In: S. Swain, M. Edwards (eds.), Approaching Late Antiquity. Oxford, 211–234.
Elm, S. 2003: Hellenism and historiography: Gregory and Julian in dialogue. In: Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 33, 493–515.
Elm, S. 2012: Sons of Hellenism, Fathers of the Church. Emperor Julian, Gregory of Nazianzus, and the Vision of Rome. Berkeley–Los Angeles–London.
Elm, S. 2017: The letter collection of the Emperor Julian. In: C. Sogno, B. K. Storin, E. J. Watts (eds.), Late Antique Letter Collections: A Critical Introduction and Reference Guide. Oakland, 54–68.
Flinterman, J.-J. 1995: Power, paideia and Pythagorianism. Greek Identity, Conceptions of the Relationship between Philosophers and Monarchs and Political Ideas in Philostratus’ Life of Apollonius. Amsterdam.
Foerster, R. (ed.) 1963: Libanius. Opera. 12 vols. Leipzig.
Follet, S. 1991: Divers aspects de l’hellénisme chez Philostrate. In: S. Saїd (ed.), ἙΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ. Quelques jalons pour une histoire de l’identité grecque. Actes du Colloque de Strasburg 25–27 octobre. Leiden, 205–216.
Fortin, E.L. 1996: Christianity and Hellenism in Basil the Great’s address Ad Adulescentes. In: J. Brian Benestad (ed.), The Birth of Philosophic Christianity: Studies in Early Christian and Medieval Thought. Lanham, 137–151.
Fox, R.L. 1986: Pagans and Christians. Suffolk.
Giangrande, J.G. (ed.) 1956: Eunapius. Vitae sophistarum. Rome.
Goldhill, S. 2006: Artemis and cultural identity in Empire culture: How to think about polytheism, now? In: D. Konstan, S. Saïd (eds.), Greek on Greekness. Viewing the Greek Past under the Roman Empire. Cambridge, 112–161.
Gschnitzer, F., Högemann, P. 2006: Hellas. In: H. Cancik, H. Schneider (eds.), Brill’s New Pauly. URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/1574–9347_bnp_e506760; accessed on: 14.02.2022.
Hahn, J. 2008: The conversion of the cult statues: The destruction of the Serapeum 392 AD and the transformation of Alexandria into the “Christ-loving” city. In: J. Hahn, S. E. Emmel, U. Gotter (eds.), From Temple to Church: Destruction and Renewal of Local Cultic Topography in Late Antiquity. Leiden, 336–367.
Hall, J.M. 2002: Hellenicity. Between Ethnicity and Culture. Chicago–London.
Impellizzeri, S. 1983: Basilio e l’Ellenismo. In: Basilio di Cesarea: La sua età, la sua opera e il basilianesimo in Sicilia. Vol. 2. Messine, 959–977.
Jaeger, W. 1963: Das frühe Christentum und die griechische Bildung. Berlin.
Jones, C.P. 2004: Multiple identities in the Age of the Second Sophistic. In: B. E. Borg (ed.). Paideia: The World of the Second Sophistic. Berlin, 13–21.
Konstan, D., Saïd, S. (eds.) 2006: Greek on Greekness. Viewing the Greek Past under the Roman Empire. Cambridge.
Kurmann, A. (ed.) 1988: Gregor von Nazianz. Oratio 4 gegen Julian. Basel.
Lacombrade, C. 1958: L’hellénisme de Julien et les lettres grecques. Pallas. Revue d’études antiques 6, 21–38.
Laistner, M.L.W. 1967: Christianity and Pagan Culture in the Later Roman Empire. Ithaka, N.Y.
Marcone, A. 2020: Pagan reactions to Julian. In: S. Rebenich, H.-U. Wiemer (eds.), A Companion to Julian the Apostate. Leiden, 326–359.
Masaracchia, E. (ed.) 1990: Giuliano Imperatore. Contra Galilaeos. Roma.
Millar, F. 2006: Rome, the Greek world and the East. Vol. 3. The Greek World, the Jews and the East. North Caroline.
Nesselrath, H.-G. 2014: Libanius and the literary tradition. In: L. Van Hoof (ed.), Libanius. A Critical Introduction. Cambridge, 241–267.
Nesselrath, T. 2013: Kaiser Julian und die Repaganisierung des Reiches. Konzept und Verbilder. Münster.
Penella, R.J. 1990: Greek Philosophers and Sophists in the Fourth Century A. D. Studies in Eunapius of Sardis. Leeds.
Penella, R.J. 2007: Man and the Word. The Orations of Himerius. Berkeley–Los Angeles–London.
Rappe, S. 2001: The new math: How to add and to subtract pagan elements in Christian education. In: Y. L. Too (ed.), Education in Greek and Roman Antiquity. Leiden, 405–432.
Rousselle, A. 2001: Images as education in the Roman Empire (second-third centuries AD). In: Y. L. Too (ed.), Education in Greek and Roman Antiquity. Leiden, 373–403.
Saїd, S. 2006: The rewriting of the Athenian past from Isocrates to Aelius Aristides. In: D. Konstan, S. Saїd (eds.), Greek on Greekness. Viewing the Greek Past under the Roman Empire. Cambridge, 47–60.
Schouler, B. 1991: Hellénisme et humanisme chez Libanios. In: S. Saїd (ed.), ἙΛΛΗΝΙΣΜΟΣ. Quelques jalons pour une histoire de l’identité grecque. Actes du Colloque de Strasburg 25–27 octobre. Leiden, 267–286.
Smith, R. 1995: Julian’s Gods. Religion and Philosophy in the Thought and Action of Julian the Apostate. London–New York.
Stenger, J. 2009: Hellenische Identität in der Spätantike. Griechische Autoren und ihr Unbehagen an der eigenen Zeit. Berlin–New York.
Stenger, J.R. 2014: Libanius and the “game” of Hellenism. In: L. Van Hoof (ed.), Libanius. A Critical Introduction. Cambridge, 268–292.
Stenger, J.R. 2018: The “pagans” of Late Antiquity. In: J. Lössl, N. J. Baker-Brian (eds.), Companion to Religion in Late Antiquity. New York, 391–410.
Van Nuffelen, P. 2014: Not the last pagan: Libanius between elite rhetoric and religion. In: L. Van Hoof (ed.), Libanius: A Critical Introduction. Cambridge, 293–314.
Yıldırım, B. 2004: Identities and Empire: Local mythology and the self-representation of Aphrodisias. In: L. Van Hoof (ed.), Paideia: The World of the Second Sophistic. Berlin, 23–52.