1. Journal of Ancient History 2 (76)
  2. Some Considerations about the Discussion between L.L. Kofanov and A.L. Smyshlyaev (VDI 2014, no. 4; 2015, no. 4; 2016, no. 2)

Some Considerations about the Discussion between L.L. Kofanov and A.L. Smyshlyaev (VDI 2014, no. 4; 2015, no. 4; 2016, no. 2)

Smorchkov Andrey M.

The paper reviews problems and results of the discussion (refl ected in four articles) between L.L. Kofanov and A.L. Smyshlyayev concerning the role of Roman jurists and their consensual responses in the development of the Roman law.

Keywords: Roman Republic, jurists, priests, honor, ius respondendi, contiones
References:

Gaius, 1904: Gai Institutiones, or Institutes of Roman Law by Gaius. With a transl. and comm. by E. Poste. 4 ed. Oxford.

Gaius, 1997: Institutsii. Knigi 1–4 [Institutiones. Books I–IV. Transl. by F. Dydynskiy; ed. by V.A. Savel’ev, L.L. Kofanov]. Moscow.

Гай. Институции. Книги 1–4.  Пер. с лат. Ф. Дыдынского; под ред. В.А. Савельева, Л.Л. Кофанова. М.

Dvoretskiy, I.Kh. 1986: Latinsko-russkiy slovar’. Izd. 3 [Latin-Russian dictionary. 3rd ed.]. Moscow.

Дворецкий, И.Х. Латинско-русский словарь. Изд. 3. М.

Dozhdev, D.V. 1996: Pimskoe chastnoe pravo. Uchebnik dlya vuzov [Roman private law. A Handbook]. Moscow.

Дождев, Д.В. Римское частное право. Учебник для вузов. М.

Dydynskiy, F.M. 1997: Latinsko-russkiy slovar’ k istochnikam rimskogo prava. Po izdaniyu 1896 goda [Latin-Russian dictionary of the sources of Roman law. Based on the 1896 edition]. Moscow.

Дыдынский, Ф.М. Латинско-русский словарь к источникам римского права. По изданию 1896 года. М.

Kofanov, L.L. 2014: Rol’ responsa rimskikh yuristov v disputatio forensis v rimskoy grazhdanskoy obshchine V–I vv. do n.e. [The role of responsa of Roman jurists in the disputatio forensis of Roman civil community in 5th–1st centuries BC]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 87–110.

Кофанов, Л.Л. Роль responsa римских юристов в disputatio forensis в римской гражданской общине V–I вв. до н.э. ВДИ 4, 87–110.

Kofanov, L.L. 2015: Eshche raz o disputatio fori i responsa prudentium: otvet A.L. Smyshlaevu [Once again about disputatio fori and responsa prudentium: in Reply to A.L. Smyshlyaev ]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 240–256.

Кофанов, Л.Л. Еще раз о disputatio fori и responsa prudentium: ответ А.Л. Смышляеву. ВДИ 4, 240–256.

Linderski, J. 1986: Religion aspects of the conflict of the orders. In: K.A. Raaflaub (ed.), Social struggles in archaic Rome. New perspectives on the conflict of the orders. London, 244–261.

Petruchenko, O.A. 1914: Latinsko-russkiy slovar’. Izd. 9-e [Latin-Russian dictionary. 9 ed.]. Moscow.

Петрученко, О.А. Латинско-русский словарь. Изд. 9-е. М.

Smorchkov, A.M. 2010: Drevnerimskoe zhrechestvo i senat (po povodu kontseptsii R. Mitchella) [The priests of ancient Rome and the senate (on the concept of R. Mitchell)]. In: Indoevropeyskaya istoriya v svete novykh issledovaniy [Indo-European history in the light of new researches]. Moscow, 321–327.

Сморчков, А.М. Древнеримское жречество и сенат (по поводу концепции Р. Митчелла). В сб.: Индоевропейская история в свете новых исследований. М., 321–327.

Smorchkov, A.M. 2012: Religiya i vlast’ v Rimskoy respublike: magistraty, zhretsi, khramy. [Religion and authorities in the Roman Republic: magistrates, priests, temples]. Moscow.

Сморчков, А.М. Религия и власть в Римской республике: магистраты, жрецы, храмы. М.

Smorchkov, A.M. 2014: Konsultatsii zhretsov v sfere publichnogo prava Rimskoy respubliki [Consultations of priests in the sphere of public law of the Roman Republic]. IVS ANTIQVVM. Drevnee pravo [Ancient Law] 1 (29), 38–68.  

Сморчков, А.М. Консультации жрецов в сфере публичного права Римской республики. Древнее право 1 (29), 38–68.

Smyshlyaev, A.L. 2014: Eshche raz o disputatio fori i responsa prudentium [Once more on responsa of Roman jurists and disputatio fori]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 110–129.

Смышляев, А.Л. Еще раз о responsa римских юристов и disputatio fori. ВДИ 4, 110–129.

Smyshlyaev, A.L. 2016: Kommentariy k stat'e L.L. Kofanova “Eshche raz o disputatio fori i responsa prudentium: otvet A.L. Smyshlyaevu” (VDI. 2015. № 4) [A Commentary on L.L. Kofanov’s paper “Once again about disputatio fori and responsa prudentium: in reply to A.L. Smyshlyaev” (VDI 2015, no. 4)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 410–421.

Смышляев, А.Л. Комментарий к статье Л.Л. Кофанова «Еще раз о disputatio fori и responsa prudentium: ответ А.Л. Смышляеву» (ВДИ. 2015. № 4) ВДИ 2, 410–421.